Avoid These 10 Recruiting Mistakes

December 1, 2015

Recruitment is more than just finding a person to fill a job. It’s selecting someone who will contribute to your company’s goals, and someone who you would be willing to invest time and effort in. A lot rides on your selection, so it’s not to be taken lightly. Mistakes happen and that’s normal. The difference with recruitment is that mistakes at this stage of the employment process may have an impact in the long run, and in the bigger picture – but may be harder to remedy as time passes. To help, stay clear of these 10 mistakes to avoid during the recruitment process:

Continuing the same process.

If you find yourself in a cycle to fill certain vacancies regularly, there’s probably already something wrong internally. If you do not stop and take a look at your company, it’s practices and your own processes, you’re bound to keep repeating the same mistakes. Conduct audits and have sit-down interviews with people, especially the ones who are leaving, and find out what you’re doing wrong.

Not preparing.

Recruitment is a process. Just because you do it frequently doesn’t mean you shouldn’t prepare. Get all paperwork ready, prepare a schedule and meet with everyone involved with the process.

Not having a specific and measurable list of criteria.

Prevent having any bias opinions that may arise from their resume or interview by preparing a list of specific and measurable criteria you will use as basis for your decisions before considering any candidate. This will help you clearly sort out which candidates are qualified and those that are not.

Not providing the sufficient information.

Be sure to provide complete information about the job vacancy and the company to the candidate. Let him or her decide if he or she still wants the job, given all the information. If you withhold important details like unattractive job responsibilities, the candidate may feel cheated, much like purchasing a product based on a lie. This can lead to dissatisfaction and a premature resignation.

Rushing just to fill a gap.

Don’t breeze through the process just because of the urgency to fill a specific position. Yes, each day the vacancy is unfilled can mean less revenue, but think about the bigger picture. The loss will be much less than the costs of having the wrong person for the job.

Ignoring any warning signs.

A key quality you will want to look for in a candidate, especially if your company experiences retention concerns, is a candidate’s affinity to move on to a different job later on. Take note of the signs, such as employment history and future plans. Ask the person regarding his short and long term goals. If you feel you that the company will not able to meet them, that person will most likely not stay long.

Not including key decision makers.

As the hiring manager, you can make the decision on who to hire. But it is best to also consider the thoughts of people in the company, especially those directly affected by your decision. This mainly includes the candidate’s potential direct superiors. It’s important to have people who will be directly involved with the candidate’s work to help make a decision that is based on the needs of the company.

Throwing money on the problem.

Money is not always the solution to everything. If you are negotiating with a potential new hire, listen to what he or she is asking. Don’t always assume that candidates always seek more money in negotiations. If the candidate has reservations about accepting your offer, listen and ask what he or she is looking for. It may be flexibility, security or other non-monetary benefits. Then assess if you can and will provide these, and negotiate further.

Low balling good candidates.

On the other side of the spectrum, if you find a good candidate, don’t offer a low salary just because you can. If you present an offer that is lower than their True Market Value, it’s likely you are not treating him or her with the respect they deserve. A good candidate is a good candidate, pay them what they’re worth.

Failing to support the new hire.

Your job as a hiring manager does not end the moment the candidate signs the employment contract. You are the person’s first point of contact with the company, so you would be the person he or she may want to go to for any questions on concerns. Look after your new hire during the first few weeks. Check in regularly, and ensure that everything is well and in order. Be that person he or she can easily approach when needed.

Do any of these mistakes sound familiar? It’s ok to make them once in awhile. It’s a part of the growing experience and journey of our career. The key is to learn from them. At the end of the day, your job is to find the best people to achieve your company’s goals. Keeping this in mind will help you stay away from these mistakes.

Looking for that perfect candidate? Our 24/7 online job market place will help you find the perfect fit for your job, fast.

VP of Marketing at Digital Astronauts

Ronny Cheng is one of the Co-Founder’s of Digital Astronauts and has helped drive lead generation in the software industry for organizations of all sizes — from start-ups to Fortune 500’s. He helped build one of the first online software review websites, specializing in CRM, ERP, and HR software. He’s a nationally published author with extensive experience working with the HR/Recruiting industries largest brands. In his spare time, you can catch him on Instagram doing his best food blogger impersonation.


Leave a Comment

The access_token provided is invalid.


Thanks for visiting the SkillGigs Facebook page! By using or accessing our Facebook page, you agree to comply with Facebook's Statement of Rights and Responsibilities. As always, the content posted by fans of SkillGigs' Facebook page does not reflect SkillGigs' views or opinions. Just because you see content from other fans of SkillGigs does not mean SkillGigs confirms the accuracy that content. Our hope is that your experience on our Facebook page is just as awesome as your SkillGigs experience on our website. That’s why we’re asking all of our fans to follow a few guidelines to help maintain this standard. Please do not post content that: is fraudulent, deceptive or misleading; is threatening, abusive, defamatory, obscene, indecent or objectionable; violates any law or regulation; violates the intellectual property rights of another; is hateful or otherwise targets race, religion, political beliefs, ethnicity, gender, sex, or nationality; is spamming (including link baiting) or commercial in nature; or is otherwise offensive. We reserve the right to remove any posts that violate these guidelines or that we otherwise determine are not appropriate. By posting content on our page, you hereby grant to SkillGigs a worldwide, royalty-free license to use and fully exploit the content in any manner or media, forever, without any obligation to you. This includes the right to use any ideas you submit (including ideas about our products or advertising campaigns) in any manner that we choose, without any obligation to you.
SkillGigsTuesday, August 22nd, 2017 at 2:25am Attracting #talent has become so creative! Check out how these companies support #employees with their families, education, community & more. #employeeperks #sabbatical #PTO
SkillGigsMonday, August 21st, 2017 at 12:03pm #SkillGiggers, I believe you deserve your market price...or anything more if you can swing it. Here are my tips for approaching the daunting topic - #salarynegotiation
SkillGigsSunday, August 20th, 2017 at 8:56am
Employers or hiring managers, you may know to make a good first impression with potential #talent by sharing the company benefits & activities, but how do you get them excited for the actual job? As we are in #tech, we are passionate about providing innovation junkies. Check out a few of my methods for charging up the talent. #hackathons
SkillGigsSaturday, August 19th, 2017 at 11:35am
Our tool offers candidates with all kinds of job type preferences. We know startups need to grow and the need to grow fast. Check out George Deeb's advice on when to hire #employees, #contractors or crowdsources for your #startup.
SkillGigsSaturday, August 19th, 2017 at 6:29am
12 Innovative Recruiting Strategies That Savvy Companies are Using via @hireonlinkedin gives you the cheat sheet on what top companies are doing to hire talent. I have to say - some of these methods are seriously cut throat!
SkillGigsSaturday, August 19th, 2017 at 2:11am I understand the struggle of making big #hiring decisions! If you are unsure about your current #sourcing processes, feel free to download our free #HiringManager Satisfaction survey.
SkillGigs - Job Searching Tips - Recruiting & Sourcing Advice